Forum

> > Unreal Software > voting for removing the file review
Forums overviewUnreal Software overviewLog in to reply

English voting for removing the file review

13 replies
To the start Previous 1 Next To the start

Poll Poll

YOUR VOTE IS :

Only registered users are allowed to vote
Yes
12.82% (5)
No
84.62% (33)
Maybe
2.56% (1)
39 votes cast

old Re: voting for removing the file review

DC
Admin On Online

Quote
Could you please explain why you want the new review system to be removed? What's bad about it in your opinion?

Edit:
Oh I see. Some of your files got declined. I'm sorry about this but this doesn't mean that the system itself is the problem. Maybe your files are not good enough. Did you consider this already? No offense. Just something to think about.
edited 1×, last 01.12.15 11:47:46 pm

old Re: voting for removing the file review

SQ
Moderator Off Offline

Quote
Because everyone were sarcastic and gave you likes just because they were joking around. I'm sorry that you were a victim of this case.

old Re: voting for removing the file review

VADemon
User Off Offline

Quote

First of all: it's "replace" not "remplace" ×
• You wrote the descriptions in like 3 minutes; practically unreadable
• You "AK-Skin" is in fact 2 colors with some ~shading~. And it looks orange, not wooden.
• Your flare replacement is okay-ish.
• IMHO: Your molotov cocktail bottle is a little too wide, but it also looks cartoonish. If so, then you probably should label it properly "cartoon molotov" or something.

Again, I'm not a sprite expert and I usually stick to vanilla graphics/components.

PS: Just noticed the glorious pink on my screenshot. I'll roll out an update this weekend, hopefully.

PPS: I would discard the following uploads of mine:
• file cs2d [ADMN, DEV] Permissions - WIP - Not nearly done, user-unfriendly, the file ID is not 15555
• file cs2d [MECH] Balanced medic armor - Too simple, a few lines of code. (maybe good for noobs, but idk)
• file cs2d [DEV] Better rounding (forget math.round() !) - Yates provided a shorter example of code in the comments, the solution is somewhat easy to find on the internet. Should be included in Lua anyway

old Re: voting for removing the file review

GeoB99
Moderator Off Offline

Quote
Basically, you want the Re-viewer system to be removed from the website just because you're crying that your file is declined? 'facepalm'

Honestly, you're embarrassing yourself with this thread and the moderator who declined your file is perfectly justified. Besides, your Tommy gun is really horrible (the shape is really bad and it does not even fit completely - one of the main reason why its quality is really poor).

old Re: voting for removing the file review

Styx
User Off Offline

Quote
@user MaxmyA_TN: Don't complain about this new system. It's really necessary now. If you still have a problem , then try to improve your file. After that, your file will may have a chance to get approved.

old Re: voting for removing the file review

EngiN33R
Moderator Off Offline

Quote
Negative feedback is also feedback, and often better than a simple "hey nice job" if it's constructive. Take user DC's words to heart and use this as an opportunity to improve. If you go into it with a clear and positive mind you'll find that people will welcome the changes that you've made to yourself and your work. And much like user VADemon, I'd decline a few of my own files in a heartbeat.
To the start Previous 1 Next To the start
Log in to replyUnreal Software overviewForums overview