English New Rating System

93 replies
Goto Page
To the start Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next To the start
08.11.11 04:14:40 pm
Up
0a
User
Offline Off
How to turn Unreal Software to Facebook
user 0a like this.
08.11.11 04:43:14 pm
Up
Krimhorn
User
Offline Off
Yea, actually U.S. is on good way to have rate system like on Faic(ce)book.
08.11.11 06:24:39 pm
Up
Doberman
User
Offline Off
The ratings and comments wouldn't be too bad if people were actually capable of writing constructive criticism instead of "THIS IS SHIT LOL!!11ONE1!!".

The other thing is that the uploaders need to accept that not everybody is going to like your work, even if you and some other people consider it "good". I know some people like the RPG LUA scripts for CS2D and I personally hate them.
09.11.11 04:13:54 am
Up
Majatek
User
Offline Off
user EngiN33R has written:
It doesn't make that much sense Rambo, it's just like the old system. The way it is now, the amount of people who LIKE the file is shown, while the way you propose it to be, the number of people who didn't care or dislike will also be demonstrated, which is not what we want.


Here's an example of why I would like to have the ratio system implemented:

File A is crappy, and has 20 comments, 10 of them are likes
File B is really good, and has 10 comments, all of them are likes

At a glance in the file archive, they both have the same amount of likes, and when I sort by likes, file A could come on top due to them having the same likes, rather than being able to sort by the like to comment ratio to see which is truly a better submission.

Seeing as it's a "like only" system, someone who wants to abuse it can't really impact it negatively because those who don't want to search by the ratio can search by just it's likes.
All posts generated by this user derives from consensus. Upcoming project after the Halo weapons series: Mass Effect "50 shades of DC" - Analkisses#1
09.11.11 04:22:07 am
Up
oxytamine
User
Offline Off
But who cares, both files have 10 "likes", that means that they are equal.
09.11.11 04:22:21 am
Up
Apache uwu
User
Offline Off
user Majatek has written:
ratio can search by just it's likes.


+1

A ratio can really show what files people like the most. Personally I like the old system, but w/e can't please everyone.
09.11.11 04:24:34 am
Up
Majatek
User
Offline Off
user oxytamine has written:
But who cares, both files have 10 "likes", that means that they are equal.

No it doesn't, it means that 10 people liked both files, nothing more. With the ratio system I could search by which one has a higher like ratio to comments, please read and understand what I typed fully before you post.
All posts generated by this user derives from consensus. Upcoming project after the Halo weapons series: Mass Effect "50 shades of DC" - Analkisses#1
09.11.11 04:28:57 am
Up
Apache uwu
User
Offline Off
IMG:http://img256.imageshack.us/img256/7417/unledwd.png


However it would look cool to have it show up on

Code:
1
file:*****
09.11.11 04:34:58 am
Up
Majatek
User
Offline Off
user Apache uwu has written:

But I can't search by that ratio can I? I can either search only by likes, or comments.

*edit* Also if the ratio of likes to comments system was to be implemented, only the first comment by each unique user (except for the author of the file) would be counted towards the comment ratio.
edited 1×, last 09.11.11 04:45:17 am
All posts generated by this user derives from consensus. Upcoming project after the Halo weapons series: Mass Effect "50 shades of DC" - Analkisses#1
09.11.11 05:01:33 am
Up
oxytamine
User
Offline Off
Anyone wind up coding user JS for ratio sorting?
09.11.11 11:20:15 am
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
note that you would have to eliminate comments from the same author and comments from the file creator. otherwise this ratio wouldn't be correct.
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
09.11.11 11:28:05 am
Up
Majatek
User
Offline Off
user DC has written:
note that you would have to eliminate comments from the same author and comments from the file creator. otherwise this ratio wouldn't be correct.

Of course, lol, otherwise the author would be pulling the ratio down with each post as a reply to another reply, and that would be silly

I still maintain that I would love to be able to sort by the ratio in the file archive.
All posts generated by this user derives from consensus. Upcoming project after the Halo weapons series: Mass Effect "50 shades of DC" - Analkisses#1
09.11.11 02:37:23 pm
Up
DannyDeth
User
Offline Off
There is another problem with this rating system. http://www.unrealsoftware.de/files_show.php?file=8966#com84149
I mean... LOL?!
09.11.11 02:40:20 pm
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
the rating system is not the problem. that user is the problem.

he received a temp ban for being a stupid asshole. he will receive a longer temp ban if he continues and a full ban forever afterwards.

problem neutralized.
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
09.11.11 04:15:41 pm
Up
palomino
User
Offline Off
OT: What was in that file?
zugcxdxtczgvhioj
09.11.11 04:19:31 pm
Up
DC
Admin
Offline Off
the file (set of "gold" skins for cs2d) doesn't matter. it was about a user who said that the file sucks but checked the like checkbox anyway. he wanted to protest against the new system that way. it totally didn't make sense and was simply stupid.
www.UnrealSoftware.de | www.CS2D.com | www.CarnageContest.com | Use the forum & avoid PMs!
09.11.11 04:22:41 pm
Up
DannyDeth
User
Offline Off
DC, perhaps 5.1 should be changed to: Simply don't be stupid and/or an asshole.

Well, less the " " anyway.
11.11.11 01:08:55 am
Up
Ironman47
User
Offline Off
The problem I've already experienced (and I just got here) with a rating system like this is it doesn't reflect the quality of a file. I downloaded and tried a mod out yesterday, it had 18 likes but was lacking in so many ways. (to put it nicely). Another mod file had a few likes (4 or 5, I think) and was so much better.

What would be great is if you get some moderators to rate the files so a user could tell (or at least have an idea) if a file is decent or not so they won't waste they're time downloading and trying out junk. This would also encourage authors of these files to improve they're work. And discourage people from uploading junk.
...I'm just trying to survive
11.11.11 01:21:07 am
Up
J4x
User
Offline Off
What about bringing the old system back but with 3 start as lower rating and 6 as higher?

- ∗ ∗ ∗ good
- ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ Very good
- ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ Awesome!
- ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ EPIC!!
11.11.11 05:44:06 am
Up
Majatek
User
Offline Off
user J4x has written:
What about bringing the old system back but with 3 start as lower rating and 6 as higher?

- ∗ ∗ ∗ good
- ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ Very good
- ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ Awesome!
- ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ ∗ EPIC!!

That's even worse of an idea than my like-to-comment ratio suggestion.
All posts generated by this user derives from consensus. Upcoming project after the Halo weapons series: Mass Effect "50 shades of DC" - Analkisses#1
To the start Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next To the start